The members of the South African Council of Churches (SACC) have expressed deep disappointment with Judge Irma Schoeman’s verdict in Pastor Timothy Omotoso and his co-accused. The ruling, delivered in the Gqeberha High Court, has sparked outrage, with the council questioning the prosecution’s handling of the case.

“This verdict is undoubtedly a painful blow to the victims, whose lives have been profoundly affected by the alleged abuses they endured,” the SACC stated. “We salute their willingness to come forward, relive their trauma, and stand firm in their testimonies, which speaks to the immense strength and courage they possess.”

Failure of the Prosecution

In the Thursday, April 3 statement, the SACC highlighted Judge Schoeman’s remarks regarding the shortcomings in the case presented by the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). “Even a cursory review of the judgment indicates a dereliction of duty by the prosecutor and the NPA,” the council noted. The failure of the prosecution to effectively challenge the defense’s narrative played a significant role in the outcome.

“The fundamental failure of the prosecutor to cross-examine the story of the perpetrator is a monumental failure in the search for truth,” the council asserted. “Therefore, it is not that the alleged abuses did not take place – but rather that the state failed to present a coherent and robust case to challenge what the accused claimed.”

This outcome, the SACC warned, could further erode public confidence in the justice system, especially in cases of abuse and violence against women. “We cannot continue to let our women down by failing to provide the justice and protection they deserve.”

Call for Accountability and Church Introspection

In response to the verdict, the SACC urged the NPA to review the case and explore options to pursue justice. “The NPA must strengthen its protocols for prosecutorial accountability, so that victims do not suffer a double tragedy—in the abuse itself, and again in a betrayal by the prosecuting authority.”

The council also called for deep introspection within the church, condemning the existence of such allegations among religious leaders. “Churches should be sanctuaries—it is ungodly that church leaders would be the predators and aggressors seeking to take advantage of the vulnerable.”

Quoting 1 Peter 5:2-3, the SACC reminded church leaders of their sacred duty: “Be shepherds of God’s flock that is under your care, watching over them—not because you must, but because you are willing, as God wants you to be; not pursuing dishonest gain, but eager to serve.” Any deviation from this, the council stated, is a betrayal not only of the church but of God.

A Call to Protect and Uphold the Church’s Sanctity

The SACC emphasized the need to safeguard congregations and ensure that places of worship remain spaces of safety and integrity. “Those who abuse their positions must be held accountable for their actions and should not be shielded by the church. Let the church never become a refuge for criminality.”

In closing, the council reaffirmed its commitment to justice and healing. “We continue to pray for healing, justice, and the strengthening of our faith. May God guide us to uphold the sanctity of the church and protect all who seek His presence.”